---
title: "Provider scorecard: compare 3 care providers"
description: "A printable scorecard to rate up to three nursing homes, assisted living communities or agencies on the same questions, with totals and red flags."
url: https://seniorchoicecare.com/check-a-provider/provider-scorecard/
updated: 2026-10-10
site: Senior Choice Care
---

Printable tool

# Provider scorecard: compare up to three care providers

After the tours, details blur. Rate each provider on the same questions, then let the totals and red flags speak.

**2 minute read** Updated October 9, 2026Written by the Senior Choice Care team

In short

The provider scorecard lets you rate up to three care providers on the same twelve questions: license and inspections, staffing, care planning, communication, cleanliness, costs and fit. Choose Yes, Not sure or No for each. The scorecard adds up totals and counts red flags so you can compare side by side, then print it.

**Written by the Senior Choice Care team** Updated October 9, 2026. Facts are checked against the sources listed at the end of this page. General information; every family is different.

| Question |  |  |  |
|---|---|---|---|
| License is current and matches the care my parent needs |  |  |  |
| Recent inspections show no serious or repeated problems |  |  |  |
| Staffing levels were explained clearly, including nights |  |  |  |
| Staff greeted residents by name and treated them with respect |  |  |  |
| The building was clean, with no strong odors |  |  |  |
| Care plans include the family |  |  |  |
| They explained how they handle a fall or health change |  |  |  |
| Activities fit my parent's interests |  |  |  |
| All costs were given in writing |  |  |  |
| They explained what happens if needs increase |  |  |  |
| Residents or families we spoke to were positive |  |  |  |
| It is close enough for regular visits |  |  |  |
| Total |  |  |  |

Nothing you type leaves this page. "Not sure" means ask again or check the inspection record.

## Tips

- Fill it in right after each visit
- "Not sure" means check again or look at the record
- CMS notes a nearby home can matter more than a higher rating far away

## Questions families ask

### How many providers can I compare?

Up to three at a time.

### What counts as a red flag?

Any "No" answer is counted as a red flag.

### Can I print the scorecard?

Yes, with the print button.

### Is anything saved?

No. Nothing you type leaves the page.

## Sources

- [Medicare: Your Guide to Choosing a Nursing Home (02174)](https://www.medicare.gov/publications/02174-your-guide-to-choosing-a-nursing-home)
- [National Institute on Aging: How to choose a nursing home or other long-term care facility](https://www.nia.nih.gov/health/assisted-living-and-nursing-homes/how-choose-nursing-home-or-other-long-term-care-facility)
- [Medicare.gov Care Compare: nursing homes, home health agencies, hospice and more](https://www.medicare.gov/care-compare/)

## Read next

- [Check a provider](https://seniorchoicecare.com/check-a-provider/)
- [Nursing home questions](https://seniorchoicecare.com/questions-to-ask/nursing-home/)
- [Nursing home inspections](https://seniorchoicecare.com/check-a-provider/nursing-home-inspection-reports/)
- [Assisted living inspections](https://seniorchoicecare.com/check-a-provider/assisted-living-inspection-reports/)
- [Home Health Compare](https://seniorchoicecare.com/check-a-provider/home-health-compare/)
- [Hospice Compare](https://seniorchoicecare.com/check-a-provider/hospice-compare/)
- [Long-term care ombudsman](https://seniorchoicecare.com/check-a-provider/long-term-care-ombudsman/)
- [Nursing Home Compare](https://seniorchoicecare.com/check-a-provider/nursing-home-compare/)

---
Canonical page: https://seniorchoicecare.com/check-a-provider/provider-scorecard/